
Video by India Arie connects to the Womanist movement and body neutrality. It broadcasts ideologies found in the womanist movement by rejecting the ideals associated with whiteness and femininity. Black women are often ignored in the conversation about equality and representation. India Arie sings about not needing wealth or fancy things to be happy. Through this language, she is rejecting the idea of wealth in order to be feminine. This is part of what the womanist movement rejected from the first-wave feminists. First-wave feminism focused on white, upper-middle-class women instead of the intersectionality and marginalization of different women. India Arie also aims to spread body neutrality by accepting herself and not nourishing the unrealistic beauty standard. She makes references to not shaving her legs, not combing her hair, not getting plastic surgery, and not wearing pantyhose. This is deconstructing the ideals and standards set for women. In the class reading about body hair, it explains how in the late nineteenth century, body hair removal was normalized to show racial superiority and modernization. The Instagram book review writes, “Maintenance of white women’s ‘proper’ physical appearance became about maintaining ‘health’ of the white race in the face of migration and racial unrest” (@alokvmenon). This was an effort by men to control (white) women’s femininity and sexuality. The understanding of black women as inferior because they have body hair connects back to the womanist movement. The standards, acceptance, and discrimination between white and black women were very different. Black women had to deal not only with sexism but also racism. White men during this time aimed to control Black women while simultaneously interpreting them as racially inferior. The need for a movement that accepted all women regardless of race, socioeconomic status, and body size came from the rejection of Black women into the feminist movement. The chorus says, “I’m not the average girl from your video. And I ain’t built like a supermodel. But I learned to love myself unconditionally. Because I am a queen.” This song expresses modern feminist thought by inspiring women to take control of their lives and do what makes them happy. As a Black woman, India Arie tells the story of acceptance, self-love, and independence from the controlling society we live in.
This song is personally inspiring to me as a Black woman because it rejects the beauty standard that is reinforced through all aspects of society. So often, young girls are told they are too fat, too skinny, not tall enough, too tall, etc. This song teaches young girls that they are beautiful just the way they are. Unlike many current artists, India aims to empower not degrade women. I grew up listening to her in my household which I believe positively impacted my self-esteem.
I love that you mention your personal connection with the song, that’s what makes music so special is that it can make people feel real things and change them as people! This was a really interesting analysis of how the song connects to the different waves of feminism that we talked about in class and the way that the song embodies modern feminism and especially empowers Black women.
I had never heard this song before and really enjoyed listening to it! Her confidence is really refreshing, and it’s great to hear a song about someone who is able to resist beauty standards and truly enjoy who they are. So often the conversation is only about the harm created by beauty standards and their negative effects, which is an extremely important conversation to have. However, I think it’s equally important to see models of confidence in order for younger women, especially younger Black women in this situation, to be able to picture themselves as confident.
Thank you so much for your analysis. I had never heard this song before reading your analysis, and I listened afterwards and it was awesome. There are so many lines in this song that challenge society’s view of women. My favorite line was “My mama said, ‘a lady ain’t what she wears, but what she knows’.” I saw this line as directly challenging society’s frequent view of women, which is that women should be judged on how they look instead of other aspects such as their character. I also liked that this piece supports intersectionality, as India Arie is not just a woman and not just black, she is a black woman, and it is important to consider that intersecting identity.